A common mistake that is very tempting and easy for a worship leader to make is to begin bringing people into the band without taking the time to see where they are spiritually or at least understand their theology of worship. Assuming that they are on the same page as you because they go to church, play instruments/sing, or have been involved in worship before is a grave mistake. These people are going to be standing in front of everybody in your church as role models in your ministry. These people will be looked at as examples, and will be examined closely by the people. If they have the wrong heart or bad worship theology, it will hinder your ministry and possibly even discredit it.
Judging a worship leader or worship team by the response they get is not a credible method to measure successful worship. Successful worship is measured by the question "Was God glorified?" Any other means of measurement is trite and should be avoided at all cost. For this reason you should look for people to join your team who desire that God be glorified above all that they are and in all that they do. If you cannot find anyone like this, lead by yourself or with the small team you already have. Pastors, elders, the people, or even your own team may complain that the team is too small or doesn't sound "full", but be faithful to your ministry and to the glory of God. Do not give into the demands of people at the expense of the integrity of your ministry. After all is said and done, who are you seeking to please: God or man?
I would suggest to you the small worship team that sounds mediocre yet understands worship theology pleases God more than the band that sounds amazing yet leads with self-seeking intentions.
Leading worship is not a minute ministry. It is not a disposable ministry that immature people should be thrown into for the sake of the band, gratification of the people, or church attendance. Members of the worship team are leaders whether they like it or not. Members of the worship team will be held to a higher standard than everyone else. Make sure your team understands this. Make sure they understand the gravity of their position as worship leader.
Oh, how I wish this would be the understanding of every worship leader and worship team! Bigger doesn't always mean better, specifically when it's at the expense of glorifying God! Brothers and sisters, do you not understand that a self-seeking heart is rebellion against God? Do you not remember why Satan, one of the highest ranking angels, was thrown out of heaven because of his self-seeking pride? Why would you not want to make sure your worship team understands this? Why would you not educate your team on glorifying God? Are you afraid? Pray for boldness! Are you lazy? Pray for motivation! Are you apathetic? Pray for conviction! Lead your team for the glory of God!
Blessings,
Nick
